Denise: If some of your best team players are suddenly quiet, that also is a warning sign.
[0:00:10.3]
Narrator: This is the Called to Flourish podcast, where leaders and cultures grow.
[0:00:16.9]
Robert: Welcome back to the Called to Flourish podcast, where leaders and cultures grow. My name is Robert Wachter. I’m the Vice President of Sales and Marketing here at Best Christian Workplaces. And today we are joined by Denise Craig. Denise is the CEO of The Church Network, a former Executive Pastor and a church leader for more than 30 years. Denise, welcome to the podcast and please tell us a little bit more about yourself and The Church Network.
[0:00:44.6]
Denise: Thank you so much for having me, Robert. It’s a pleasure to be here today. The Church Network has been around for 70 years, and we serve church administrators, people that have a title like executive pastor, director of operations, anything in that umbrella of church administration, and we’re there primarily to educate and connect them with other people who do what they do.
[0:01:07.1]
Robert: That’s awesome. That’s awesome. We were just part of your latest conference, The Church Network Conference in Florida and had a great time. So, if you’re a church leader out there, you want to go check out The Church Network and learn more about the resources and guidance they can provide to you. So today we want to talk a little bit about how mission thriving can sometimes be a blind spot for church leaders in terms of being so focused on the mission that at times we can lose focus a little bit on the people who are carrying the mission, and I think that’s kind of a natural thing that can happen if we’re not careful and if we’re not aware as leaders. I want to talk a little bit about that. I was reminded in my prep for this podcast the old fable about the goose that laid the golden eggs. If ya’ll remember that, the farmer was so focused on the value of the eggs, these golden eggs, and in the meantime lost focus on the health of the goose. Of course, the health of the goose matters even more than the eggs because without the goose, there will be no golden eggs. I think sometimes - Denise, I’d love your perspective on this – do you think that sometimes church leaders can allow things like, you know, the metrics around the ministry of attendance and giving and programs, baptisms, the things that are so important, and perhaps that’s the reason why, they are so important that sometimes it can overshadow a focus on the internal health and what’s going on with their people in the church. Do you think that’s a likely tendency perhaps for church leaders to fall into if they’re not careful?
[0:02:47.4]
Denise: I definitely think it can be, especially for leaders that are very driven, that are very metrics oriented. The competitive nature that can reside in some leaders because they’re just charging forward, kind of like a bull in a China shop, you know, they may get to the other side, but they don’t know what kind of havoc they have wreaked from one side to the other, and I think when we consider our staff, our church staff, you know, you don’t get on the church staff because you just want to. Usually you feel a calling in your life for a bigger purpose and so embracing the people on your team as part of that mission and that it is a shared mission, it’s not the vision of one person, but it’s a shared mission among the team, and to also realize that you know, our greatest resource is our human resources. You know, often we think of finances or facilities, and those are all important, but our greatest resource is our human resources because not only do they help us accomplish the mission, but I think as leaders we always have to remember too, we’re there to disciple them as well, and sometimes that can get lost. We assume that, you know, they are in a place of their spiritual journey where maybe they don’t need discipling or that’s kind of on them to take care of their own soul, if you will, but as leaders we have the stewarding responsibility of the people placed under our care, not just our church members, but our church staff and how we steward that relationship and their health as they go along is very, very, very important as a leader.
[0:04:41.7]
Robert: Yeah. You touched on something that resonates so much with me, and I’ve mentioned this before, but I was a pastor of a church for 10 years. My wife and I planted a church in Washington state, and I fell into this trap because as a leader you’re so passionate, and you touched on this, so passionate, so committed to the mission, how the mission is so important, and I neglected my own wellbeing in that endeavor, right, and so how easy for us to also neglect the wellbeing of the organizational health of the church. So we’re talking about the health of individuals, our staff, their spiritual health, their soul, their wellbeing, but also the organizational health, the structural health, the systems and things that we are stewarding that ensure a healthy organizational culture. So I fell into that and it was a byproduct of just believing so much in the mission. Do you think that’s really – because we’re talking about wonderful people, great people, who love God, they love God’s people, they love the church so much, and you know, as a byproduct of that, how is it possible that then we can ignore or maybe have a blind spot for the internal health of what’s going on? Do you think that it’s – is it, is it just such a passion for the mission, you think, that can possibly even create a mission blind spot?
[0:06:18.2]
Denise: I think it is, and I think in those kind of situations what can easily creep in and happen is that everything becomes urgent and when everything becomes urgent in an organization, you lose discernment of prioritization, you lose discernment of pace because everything is always fast, and there are seasons when we need to step back, even as an organization. If individuals need to practice Sabbath, there’s nothing wrong with an organization occasionally going, we’re going to slow our pace down just for a little bit, give everybody time to breathe and to refresh, to refocus. I think sometimes we forget that, and we just are full speed ahead and forget that everything isn’t always urgent. If we lose the sense of prioritization, then employees can often get burnt out, you know leaders can get burnt out, because you can only run at a sprint for so long. Now there are seasons when we all have sprints. Organizations have sprints. An example could be if you’re in the middle of a software change. That’s something that usually has very critical deadlines and everybody has to kind of get focused on that. It could be a construction project and you have an opening date of a new facility and you need to all kind of – everybody on deck to make that happen. But those seasons of sprint, once they become all the time, I think that’s when things can really get way out of whack and priorities can get out of order. I just think that’s something we need to consider is pace and that everything is not always urgent.
[0:08:07.9]
Narrator: Leading well starts with listening well. At Best Christian Workplaces, our Employee Engagement Survey helps you collect honest, anonymous feedback from your staff so you can lead with clarity. When you understand what drives team engagement, you retain top talent, increase productivity, reduce turnover, and uncover cost savings. We equip Christian leaders with research-driven insight to strengthen culture and lead with purpose. Because when your people flourish, your mission impact multiplies. Visit workplaces.org to learn more today.
[0:08:43.4]
Robert: I love that, that idea of the Sabbatical. There is a time to sprint, but if you’re sprinting constantly in every season, the mission does always feel so urgent, doesn’t it, because we’re talking about souls and we’re talking about lives and eternity. That’s such an easy thing to fall into. I was also thinking about this idea that the mission outcomes can be so much more visible than maybe an internal, invisible struggle that’s happening, if that makes sense. We see how many people are attending. We see how much money is coming in. We see the building projects. Those are very visible mission outcomes that we’re measuring. But internal tensions and staff struggles or you know tiredness, weariness, can be very invisible. It can creep slowly into a culture. So I was wondering if that’s maybe something that can happen. It’s just not as easy to see all the time. It’s not as prevalent as maybe the missional outcomes and those measurements might be.
[0:09:50.1]
Denise: I agree, and sometimes it’s harder to quantify also. You know, it’s not as easy as counting how many people were here on Sunday. It takes listening. It takes observing. It takes slowing down long enough to realize the people dynamics happening in a room, you know, so it definitely takes some emotional intelligence, some awareness of what’s going on around you. We can get so focused on the mission, like you mentioned earlier, that we don’t really see what’s happening right around us. So I think just a holy awareness, a discernment from the Lord, to ask Him to give you eyes to see and ears to hear those things that are happening right around you, you know. We can learn a lot from listening and observing, and I think sometimes we can get so focused on the doing, the saying, we forget the listening and observing and how important that is as well.
[0:10:47.2]
Robert: Yes, listening and observing. That’s – you know, we’re thinking about mission and you’ve been around so many churches for so long, and we see this all the time as well, at Best Christian Workplaces, is that sometimes the mission, the church, the organization can be very successful. The metrics are being met, you know, the funds are coming in. Souls are being saved. God’s working mightily and that can sometimes even mask the interval things that might be happening where the people really are struggling, and that discernment and that listening becomes even more important because I think it’s easy for a leader to say, well, look at – look at what God’s doing here. I mean, we are – we are really making an impact and then again, the goose is sort of behind the scenes, kind of quietly struggling and not feeling well. Ultimately, that’s going to catch up to us. I want to touch on this part of it as kind of, you know, you have been around so many churches. You’ve probably seen it all, and internal struggles, as you mentioned, if you are not observing, if you’re not listening, if you’re not engaging in some kind of measurement technique and approach, eventually those internal quiet struggles, unspoken struggles and tensions and things that are happening in the culture will become visible at some point. And so, I want to ask you, Denise, you know, in the work that you’ve done over the years, what kind of warning signs, I guess, have you seen that may suggest that something might not be healthy internally in a church?
[0:12:27.2]
Denise: I think if you see staff members being snappy with one another, resentment can creep in, lots of after-hours calls occurring, the sort of out-of-the norm, you know, lots of programming on the calendar, and staff not having a lot of family time or personal spiritual time, I think those are some things that can happen without us even realizing that they’re happening. We think programming and having the church calendar full is the thing to do, but I’ve often thought, you know, if as a church if we are a pro-family organization, if we are a pro-spiritual health organization, are we actually allowing people time to do those things? You know, if we are about personal discipleship, are we allowing people to have time to meet one on one with each other? That it doesn’t have to be a program at the church for that to occur. So, you know, I think there are several warning signs. I think we also can look for times when employees suddenly get quiet. That can be a warning sign. If someone doesn’t feel like they can give feedback or if they feel like something’s going the wrong direction and they can’t give a, hey, I see a potential problem coming, if they can’t speak up in that sort of way in a healthy – and get a healthy response from that, they will eventually stop talking, and so if some of your best team players are suddenly quiet, that also is a warning sign. Sometimes we think the opposite, you know people acting out, or whatever, and that might be the case in some situations, but also if your best players are getting really quiet, that is also a warning sign.
[0:14:37.8]
Robert: That is so, so true because behind the quietness there is something happening. There is a trust decline, a communication decline, where people become guarded, they don’t feel like they can speak out honestly and those kinds of things. That – that is really insightful. It’s not just the – maybe the very obvious, you know, friction and things that can happen in an unhealthy culture sometimes. Often it’s just silences, no longer being willing to speak out and speak up and be honest, which you desperately need in any leadership culture and a group of people building something that’s important. You’ve got to be able to come to the table and speak and shine light on things and you know, provide that insight and that value. Of course, ultimately, you know, if you’re seeing turnover, people are leaving, and you’re asking the question, you know, why is this happening? And you begin to see that pattern, that’s just going to provide a huge financial strain and just a major organizational drag. That’s another very obvious sign - wasn’t expecting that. That person left the organization, and when you start to see that, that’s a really tough one. Yeah.
[0:15:58.7]
Denise: And Robert, I think the opposite can also be true where you have longevity, but performance is going down, and that kind of can tell you that, you know, standards are not being held. There is some accountability that’s not being had. So yeah, either of those extremes can definitely be problematic.
[0:16:19.3]
Robert: Yeah. And when we’re talking about this, kind of kicking these ideas back and forth, it just reminds me of how – how difficult it is to sort of pick up on these things, you know, using your own intuition, you know. It - you could - it could be looked like one way or the other, two extremes that we’re talking about. It could be too much silence. It could be something that’s very visible. It could be longevity even, but there’s a decline in performance. There’s a decline in accountability or it could be turnover, which kind of, you know, it is very difficult as a leader to really understand the health of your culture without some kind of tool to measure, you know, what’s really going on under the hood, and it kind of leads to, of course, that’s what we do at Best Christian Workplaces is we measure. There are industrial and organizational components behind this that are very, very helpful in taking the guesswork out of what’s actually happening, and so, you know, I want to talk to you about and really get your insights on kind of the leadership shift that I think we’re getting at here because, you know, I think the greatest breakthroughs happen when there is a mental shift with leaders because that shift has to happen before action happens. There has to be a new perspective before you’re going to take some step to make improvements as a leader in an organization. I think that shift, for some leaders, is possibly just recognizing that organizational health isn’t separate from the mission. You touched on this earlier. You are called to care for the people who are carrying the mission. Would you say that’s true? I mean, is that - possibly the greatest mental shift here is, hey, you care about the mission, you have to start with the people carrying the mission.
[0:18:22.4]
Denise: Absolutely. Because the people are our mission. I mean, and sometimes again, yeah, we see the bigger picture, and we forget the people that are right in front of us. You know, the people are our mission. And two, I think we can get very wrapped up in our calling when we work in a church and we feel the pressure of God’s expectations on us and what we need to accomplish. But at the same time, we need to be careful because sometimes that can become unhealthy and almost become an idol in our lives. We need to remember that yes, our calling is important, but our relationship is with the Caller, and our relationship is with the people that He’s placed in our paths on this journey. So, we need to be really careful and sometimes that drive we feel, we need to do a little bit of a check sometime. Is this really about accountability and doing what God has asked me to do? Is this my own competitive spirit? Is this me really putting my calling on some kind of an idol pedestal? Searching ourselves is something we need to do too. I mean, leading other people is challenging enough, but leading ourselves is even harder, so, I think that’s something we need to remember too, to make sure that as a leader we’re keeping our own soul health in perspective so that we in turn can be more Christlike, we can be more loving, we can be more visionary in what God has called us to do and ensuring that we’re bringing people along with us on the journey. So our own soul health and our leader care is very important in all of this too because the Bible says we should love our neighbor as our ourself, and sometimes we can – we can get really lost in all that. We can forget about the people right in front of us too, as you’ve mentioned. So, it’s a lot to think through as a leader. I mean, leaders do have a lot on them. They’ve got budgets. They’ve got personnel issues. They’ve got facility issues. They have committees that they oversee. It’s a whole lot on the plate, so making sure you find some time every single day to pull away from the noise and take care of your own soul, your own relationship with God. Because the reality is, there’s a lot of Bible stuff going on at church. You can sit in church and hear sermons. You can sit in staff meetings and hear devotionals and think you’re caring for your soul, but really, it’s a personal responsibility to find that personal time to do that and then to turn and invest that spiritual health in other people so that they also can be healthy in their own leadership. It is a discipleship – it is a discipleship issue really.
[0:21:38.2]
Robert: Yeah. Yeah. I want to ask you, could you just speak to leaders that are listening right now and they’re – boy, oh boy, okay, I’m responsible for leading this church. You know, in Proverbs 27:23 it says, “Be sure you know the condition of your flocks. Give careful attention to your herds.” And there are leaders listening who recognize that mental shift is beginning to happen where, hey, maybe I’ve been so caught up in the calling and the mission and the souls and all of these things that are – are so good, but perhaps I’ve been neglecting the internal state of my own, my own leadership, my own relationship with God, and also there are the people that are carrying the mission and you’re recognizing, boy, maybe I’m susceptible to this. What would you say to that leader to encourage them or maybe what would be a good next step for them to – as they’re processing all of this and feeling the weight of this?
[0:22:45.5]
Denise: I really like that analogy because as leaders in the church we often think of the analogy of a shepherd, one caring for the flock, and also, knowing that the Scripture tells us to count the cost. So, every time we make a decision, we should count the cost, and the cost should not be the sheep. That should not be the cost. Every time we say “yes” to something, we are saying “no” to something else. So, realizing when we make decisions there is a cost to that, and it doesn’t need to be those sheep that have been put under our care because really, I believe we’re going to be held accountable for that as leaders.
[0:23:35.2]
Robert: Absolutely. Absolutely. Count the cost. Understand that - I love that idea that you can say “yes” to something, but you’re saying “no” to something else, and be sure that that “no” is not going to be a negative impact on the condition of your flock, and by flock we’re not just talking about the congregation. We are talking about your staff, your volunteers, the people carrying the mission and they need to be – you know the Bible says charity starts at home. I think sometimes we think that’s out of, you know, priority, that – that out of priority, but it’s really out of purity, that if we are caring for the lost and we’re seeking to disciple people in the congregation while ignoring our own staff and our own internal, you know, folks that are carrying that, that’s a purity issue where I’m neglecting this group in favor of this group kind of thing, or without even knowing it, and so, yeah, I think that plays in really well. Yeah. So, any other final thoughts you’d want to share with leaders, Denise, that are, yeah, feeling the weight of this and maybe feel like, you know, where do I go from here?
[0:24:52.7]
Denise: Well, just as an encouragement, being a leader is not easy, and so if you feel challenged, if you feel a little bit lonely, we hear sometimes it can be lonely at the top, and often leaders can feel lonely. There are other people who understand. Find a network of people who can relate to what you’re going through and share in their own journeys. That is often very encouraging so that people don’t feel alone. So, if you’re a leader, find a group that you can connect with to help you, encourage you, along your journey, and just remember, you are never alone. The Lord is always with you. He will never leave you. He will never forsake you. Even if you feel lonely, it doesn’t mean that you’re actually alone.
[0:25:45.3]
Robert: Very, very helpful. Thank you so much, Denise. Again, she’s talking about, you know, find a group, find a network. The Church Network is a great place to consider and go look and if not, you know, find some leaders. Get part of a local church prayer – a group of local lead pastors. That’s what I was part of for many, many years. It was so helpful. Start there if you don’t have that network and you are feeling alone as a leader. You can glean so many great insights and just support and encouragement from other leaders who understand what it means to sit in that leadership position that you’re in and to lead from that place. So, very, very helpful, Denise. Thank you so much for being on the podcast. I hope this is the first of many times that we get to interact with you and with The Church Network. But God bless you. Thank you so much for spending time with us today, Denise.
[0:26:36.5]
Denise: Absolutely. It has been great to be here with you, Robert.
[0:26:39.8]
Robert: Amen, and for all of our listeners, if this podcast was encouraging to you, and if you feel it would be encouraging to anyone you know, a colleague, a peer, a pastor, maybe your own pastor, maybe you came across this podcast and hey, I want to share this with my pastor, just share it. Click share. Send it out to your pastor or colleague or a friend and also you want to subscribe to the podcast. You don’t want to miss the next episode, so subscribe and share. Thank you so much for listening. Until we see you next time, God bless.