4 min read

What Leaders Believe, What Employees Experience

What Leaders Believe, What Employees Experience
Among senior leaders, 77 percent believe employee suggestions are acted on. Among individual contributors, 60 percent do.

Leaders invite ideas at team meetings, keep an open door policy, and read every comment on their engagement survey. They believe they are listening. Do the people they lead agree?

Our Employee Engagement Survey asks each person their role, so we can answer that question directly. We examined responses from 32,000 employees across every sector we serve, from the surveys behind our 2026 State of the Christian Workplace report. On each of the survey's 56 core statements, we compared the percentage of senior leaders and of individual contributors (employees who do not supervise others) who agree or strongly agree.

WHAT WE FOUND

Senior leaders are more positive on 55 of the 56 statements. That is no surprise: leaders shape the organization and tend to see it more favorably. What matters is where the gaps are widest and where they nearly disappear.

Some of the widest gaps are about voice: whether employees' ideas are asked for, whether anything happens when they offer them, and whether leaders explain their decisions.

Where perceptions differ most

Percent who agree or strongly agree

My organization acts on the suggestions of staff/employees.
Senior leaders
 
77%
Individual contributors
 
60%
My organization involves staff/employees in decisions that affect them.
Senior leaders
 
76%
Individual contributors
 
61%
My organization seeks the suggestions of staff/employees.
Senior leaders
 
84%
Individual contributors
 
71%
Leaders at my organization explain the reasons behind major decisions.
Senior leaders
 
84%
Individual contributors
 
74%

The gap grows as the question moves from asking for ideas to acting on them: 13 points on whether suggestions are sought, 17 points on whether they are acted on. The gap on whether suggestions are acted on appears in every sector we serve. It is smallest in parachurch and missions organizations (10 points) and largest in Christian higher education (23 points), with Christian K-12 schools close behind (22 points).

Pay and advancement show wide gaps too, though part of those gaps reflects differences between sectors (more on that below). On pay, 72 percent of senior leaders agree with the statement In comparison with people in similar jobs in other organizations, I feel I am paid fairly. Among individual contributors, 54 percent agree. The pattern is similar for whether the organization rewards top performers (63 percent of senior leaders agree, 48 percent of individual contributors agree) and promotes highly capable employees (77 percent versus 62 percent).

The gap is not everywhere.

Where perceptions are nearly identical

Percent who agree or strongly agree

In my area we work effectively as a team.
Senior leaders
 
93%
Individual contributors
 
91%
My supervisor helps me to solve work-related problems.
Senior leaders
 
93%
Individual contributors
 
91%
I know what is expected of me.
Senior leaders
 
93%
Individual contributors
 
92%

On teamwork, supervisor support, and knowing what is expected, the two groups answer almost alike. In fact, the one statement on which individual contributors are more positive than senior leaders is about their coworkers' skill at resolving conflict. Because individual contributors rate their teams and supervisors almost as highly as leaders do, the voice gap cannot be dismissed as general negativity on behalf of frontline employees. They are telling us something specific about whether their ideas count.

What about the managers and supervisors in between? Taking all sectors together, they answer much more like individual contributors than like senior leaders. So, the gap is not simply between those who supervise and those who do not. It sits between the people who make organization-wide decisions and everyone else.

WHAT OTHERS HAVE FOUND

Writing in Harvard Business Review in 2016, management researchers James Detert and Ethan Burris report that employees often hold back ideas and concerns, even from leaders who believe their door is open. They point to two reasons: fear of what might happen, and a belief that speaking up will change nothing. When input does not lead to visible action, people stop offering it. Our widest voice gap speaks to that second reason: whether suggestions are acted on.

WHAT THIS DOES AND DOES NOT MEAN

Senior leaders are often rating their own decisions, and some of the gaps may reflect what they can see and others cannot: suggestions that were considered and declined, or changes made without anyone connecting them to the person who suggested them.

These figures describe how people see their organization in a single year, not a record of what organizations actually did. Part of the pay and advancement gap comes from where people work: sectors where pay scores run lower also employ more individual contributors. The voice gap does not shrink when we account for this, and it appears in every sector.

Even so, what individual contributors perceive is what they experience, and it is the view leaders are least able to see from where they sit.

NEXT STEPS

• Close the loop in public. When a suggestion leads to a change, say so, and credit the person who raised it if they are comfortable being named. When a suggestion does not lead to a change, explain why. If people never hear that their idea made a difference in the conversation, it may look to them as if it was ignored.

• Ask your managers and supervisors what they see. They are closer to what individual contributors experience, and they pass decisions along. Share the reasons behind major decisions with them early, so they can explain those decisions to their teams. Always explain in light of the mission, vision, and core values.

• Compare your own results by role. Look at how your senior leaders and your individual contributors answered the four voice statements above. The size of your own gap may tell you how perceptions differ along the organizational chart.

• Pick one recurring decision and involve the people it affects. A schedule, a policy, or a spending decision that shapes their week is a good place to start. Afterward, they will have a concrete example of their input making a difference.

AN ENCOURAGEMENT

Senior leaders and individual contributors already agree about their teams, their supervisors, and knowing what is expected. Those are attributes of a healthy workplace, and across most of the organizations we survey, they are strong. Much of the voice gap may be a difference in visibility: people cannot see what happened to their ideas. That is something leaders can change this month, one closed loop at a time.

No Progress Conversations? Employees Nearly 3x More Likely to Leave

No Progress Conversations? Employees Nearly 3x More Likely to Leave

Employees without regular progress conversations are nearly three times as likely to consider leaving. Discover what BCW research reveals about...

Read More
Remote Employees Report Higher Trust and Stronger Communication

Remote Employees Report Higher Trust and Stronger Communication

give me a metadata for this new article.. 155 max character

Read More