443: Becoming a Redemptive Leader: Surrender, Suffering, and Trusting God’s Timing

What if true leadership isn’t about chasing success—but about embracing surrender? In this episode, Rev. Dr. Nicole Massie Martin—founder and executive director of Soulfire International Ministries, COO of Christianity Today, and author of Nailing It: Why Successful Leadership Demands Suffering and Surrender—challenges today’s leadership norms with a deeply biblical vision of influence shaped by suffering, rooted identity in Christ, and the call to carry the cross.

Listen to the Audio

Listen in Apple Podcasts | Listen in Spotify  | Listen in YouTube Music

In this episode:

Key Turning Points in Nicole’s Leadership Journey

Confidence vs. Surrender

• Early ministry: Came in confident due to academic preparation. (05:38)

• Realized that actual ministry requires humility and surrender beyond book knowledge. (06:11)

Power of Collaboration

• At American Bible Society: Learned that while individual effort can go far, collaboration brings deeper, more meaningful results. (06:36)

• Strategy and creativity thrive in team settings. (06:59)

• Measuring Impact at Christianity Today

• • As Chief Impact Officer: Shifted focus from quantitative metrics to qualitative impact. (07:18)

  • Emphasis on meaningful difference over superficial numbers. (7:43)

Theology of Leadership: Redemptive & Incarnational

• Concept of Redemptive Leadership

  • Leadership isn’t always a path of upward mobility. (09:05)

  • It includes suffering and setbacks—much like Christ’s path to the cross. (09:39)

  • These lows can be redemptive and shape deeper, more Christ-centered leaders (09:47)

  • Incarnational Leadership

    • Leaders must “be with” their people, especially in suffering. (10:00)

    • Teams bring personal struggles into work—leaders must recognize and accompany them. (10:14)

    • Incarnational leadership requires carrying one’s own cross and walking with others through their pain. (10:24)

Cultural Leadership Trends and Redefining Success

• Imbalance of Triumphalism and Trauma

  • Culture pushes relentless success (American exceptionalism). (11:25)

  • This triumphalism often ignores the pain and suffering necessary for transformation. (11:40)

    • Power: Not to be hoarded but shared through the Holy Spirit. (11:49)

    • Scale: Bigger isn’t always better; depth and faithfulness matter more. (12:27)

    • Performance: Move away from performative leadership toward presence and authenticity. (12:42)

Redefining Key Leadership Concepts

• Leadership as a Reflection of the Cross

  • Crucifying worldly values leads to resurrected, Christ-honoring leadership.

  • Influence should be rooted in God’s mission, not personal greatness. (17:31)

Chronos vs. Kairos: Redefining Time for Leaders

• Leaders often feel like they’re constantly behind—on deadlines, goals, and vision—because they are bound by Chronos (chronological) time. (19:02)
• Kairos time (God’s time) calls leaders to trust in God’s timing, allowing Him to redeem lost time and accelerate outcomes as needed. (19:33)
• Jesus modeled Kairos living—He wasn’t rushed but always moved in alignment with God’s purpose and timing. (20:47)
• Nicole encourages leaders to “set their clocks” to God’s pace, resisting pressure to rush and instead being spiritually attuned to the right moments. (20:57)

From Performance-Based to Presence-Based Leadership

• Traditional leadership often rewards outcomes and efficiency, but Nicole advocates for valuing the whole person. (22:35)
• In Christian workplaces, leaders can prioritize spiritual and emotional health, not just results—something secular workplaces often can’t do. (22:41)
• An example from New Life Fellowship: staff were evaluated on whether they practiced Sabbath rest—underscoring a value for personal well-being. (23:20)
• Presence-based leadership doesn’t lower standards; it recognizes that people perform better when they are seen, valued, and spiritually grounded. (24:27)
  
  

Performance and Presence: Not Opposites, But Partners

• Nicole argues presence and performance are not mutually exclusive; the deeper the spiritual grounding, the better the performance. (24:42)
• Resistance to presence-based leadership often stems from fear that people will “slack off,” but the opposite is often true in spiritually healthy environments. (24:31)
• Thriving individuals lead to thriving organizations, especially when rest, purpose, and whole-person development are prioritized. (24:52)
  
  

The Role of the Holy Spirit in Leadership

• True transformation in leadership doesn’t come from tactics alone—it hinges on the presence and work of the Holy Spirit. (26:00)
• Nicole shared a story from her early days as COO at Christianity Today: faced with a complex budget challenge, she led her team in a posture of dependence using 2 Chronicles 20 (“We don’t know what to do, but our eyes are on You”). (26:41)
• This act of collective humility and openness to the Spirit led to a sense of shared wisdom and discernment across the team. (27:50)
• Nicole emphasizes that even with skill and experience, Christian leaders must yield to what only God can do through the Spirit. (28:19)

Read the Transcript

Read a complete, word-for-word transcript of the episode

FOLLOW OUR HOST

Follow our Host, Al Lopus, on LinkedIn & Twitter.

Email our host at al@workplaces.org